According to an artcle published by the Serasota Herald-Tribune on 7.10.2009, John Patrick McDonald Jr [aka. "Midnight," singer of Crimson Glory] succumbed to his "long battle with alcoholism," which took it's inevitable toll on his body on July 8th of that year. A band statement read, "As is the case with all truly great artists, Midnight was hounded by his demons...Despite his personal demons, we always loved him and hoped that one day he would get well."
In part 1 we looked at symbolism used by Crimson Glory, and whether there may be a cohesive theme to it all. I came to the conclusion that a vague "air of mystery" was really the only common denominator tying it all together, which Midnight seemed to take most seriously of all - possibly to the detriment of his own mental and physical health.
We noted Crimson Glory's status as early pioneers of "prog metal," and the ubiquitous comparisons to Queensryche over the years, which were not without merit. We'll explore the CG/QR connection further here, and the how Midnight's death seemed to coincide with Queensryche's somewhat underwealming rebirth.
STRANGE AND NOT SO BEAUTIFUL
While Crimson Glory's 2nd album "Transcendence" is often cited by fans as their benchmark recording, the following 1991 album "Strange and Beautiful" was taken as a sharp nose-dive. It seemed to alienate their loyal die-hard heavy metal fanbase while also failing to reach a decidedly more mainstream audience, whom they appear to have been targeting. Whether this was a "musical failure" or a "promotional failure" is up for debate, but I would guess it was an equal combination of both - along with some unfortunate timing.
Midnight had a big influence on 'Strange and Beautiful'. On our first two albums, he contributed one song for each. However, he was very adamant about contributing more of his own songs on S&B; lyrics, guitars, arrangements, ect... And it completely changed our style and musical direction to the degree that Jeff and I refused to record any more albums until we could recapture the spirit and original direction we had envisioned for the band in the beginning. - Jon Drenning
It sounds to me like Drenning is blaming Midnight's selfish musical demands for the collossal failure known as "Strange and Beautiful," which probably wasn't too good for his ego. Drenning even goes a step further, insinuating that him and Jeff Lords delivered a sort of ultimatum to Midnight, as a direct result of his apparent derailment of the band's "original spirit." Could this be what set him off into 7 years of self-imposed exile?
[Ravi Jakotia replaced Dana Burnell on drums just before the recording of "Strange and Beautiful." He has since worked with NBC, CBS, Mariah Carey, the NFL, Hugh Hefner, Gap, and all sorts of other mainstream entities.]
But was it really fair or even accurate to say that Midnight was mainly responsible for the musical direction, and ultimate failure of "Strange and Beautiful?" Drenning's quote above states him and Jeff refused to do any more recordings until they could capture the band's "original direction." Yet, the very next thing they did after replacing Midnight was take all of the most commercial aspects of S&B and fuse them into a typical 90s blend of Funk/Metal/Alternative, via the shortly lived project known as Erotic Liquid Culture [originally known as the Arizona based Crush].
["Astronomica," Crimson Glory's triumphant "return to form" album.]
THE LOST TAPE
Apparently the 90s Funk/Metal route did not pan out for the boys out in Arizona, and by 1996 they came back to Florida and knocked on Midnight's door. "but he was not interested nor was he in the right physical condition to record an album up to the band's standards." Note, this was just 5-years into Midnight's apparent 7-year self imposed exile. And while I don't like to assume the worst, stating that he wasn't in "the right physical condition" lends itself to the idea that he was hittin the bottle hard. I wonder why?
While David Van Landing [R.I.P] replaced Midnight for the Erotic Liquid Culture digression, Wade Black was chosen to fill Midnight's shoes for Crimson Glory's triumphant "return to form" album [Astronomica], which curiously did NOT include Mr Funkmeister Ravi Jakotia. And while Midnight seems to get the blame for the failures of S&B, it's noteworthy that the recording of that album coincided with Ravi joining the band, who's "more tribal" contributions to the music seemed to evade any negative scrutiny, eventually leading Drenning and co. knee deep into 90s Funk/Metal drudgery before abandoning ship and going back to square one without him. In other words, the percieved "decline" of CG seemed to start when Ravi joined, and ended when he left! To be fair though, Ravi may have just been a symptom of a larger flawed strategy concocted by the think tank at Atlantic records, but who knows for sure?
Although work on "Astronimica" probably started as early as 1996, the album didn't come out until 1999. Many fans were curious why it took 3 years for the album to come out?
Well, it is true that we completety lost all of our original source data as well as all of our backup data while recording the album the first time. We were also missing cartridges which contained data for the songs...it was very strange indeed. It caused us a lot of concern... We even contemplated leaving the state of Florida and going somewhere else to record the record to prevent this from happening again. We didn't know 'who' or 'why' anyone would do this - but whoever it was 'intentionally' did this to us. . Unfortunately, we never discovered who the culprits were. In any event, we had to completely start over. - Drenning
Now let's check back in with our friend Midnight around this time...his Wikipedia entry lists a recording called "The Lost Tape." Why does that ring a bell? Oh that's right, the guys in Crimson Glory also "lost a tape" around the same time! More specifically, they lost source "data" and "cartridges" for the as yet unreleased "Astronomica" album. According to Drenning, this theivery was done "intentionally" by someone they were never able to identify, nor could they understand the motive behind it. Drenning and co. even contemplated leaving Florida in order to avoid the same thing from happening again. Well it just so happens that Midnight moved from Florida to Texas right around this same time, just after having "lost a tape" containing 6 months worth of recordings! That is the story behind the mythical "Lost Tape" listed on Midnight's Wiki profile for 1998, which was just a year before CG released "Astronomica." In other words, right about the time Drenning says THEIR "tapes" went missing. Now I don't want to jump to any wild conclusions here, but what are the odds that the recordings CG "lost" and the ones that Midnight "lost" right around the same time, just when they were considering recording an album together again, was THE SAME RECORDING?
There are many stories about this recording. Midnight had teamed up with a local blues band and recorded Pain, Boxes, Seven Angels, Black Sheep, Monkey Song, and Tea For Two at Beyond Sound Studios in Sarasota with a guy named Angus. Full band recording. On a trip to Texas, Midnight lost the actual reel to reel multi track tape. No back ups were made and so the tape is presumed lost for good. At the time Midnight was trying to get a record deal and losing the tape was a huge setback. - allsoulsmidnight.com
Midnight eventually released a limited number of mostly acoustic oriented recordings, first under the "Songs from the Attic" moniker and then later "M," which added a few additional songs and effects. Apparently many of these were limited CD-R recordings, and are pretty rare.
Midnight again kept a pretty low profile until his trip to Greece around March, 2005, for the final mastering/production process of his album "Sakada," which we spoke of in part 1. The picture of him above playing acoustic guitar was taken from an intimate performance he gave there at a small bar or something. While the Sakata recording itself is descent enough for what it is, the footage for the above performance is not very flattering. In fact, it's kind of sad.
[The above image was taken from a video filmed in Greece in 2006. It was either the last, or one of the last performances of CG with Midnight on vocals]
[Midnight's [final?] photo session, taken for Headache Magazine. It captures a decidedly darker and somber countenance, contrasting his wild blonde look of the 80s]
METATRON, LUCIFER, AND THE DIVINE CHAOS
In April of 2006, CG announced that Midnight would be re-joining the band and singing on a new album, with the understated working title of "Metatron, Lucifer, and the Divine Chaos". It was also announced that Midnight would re-record vocals upon a newly remixed version of "Astronomica," which was supposed to be their big comback album in the late 90s. The band also announced they would be appearing (presumably with Midnight on vocals) at Rockway Festival in Greece, on May 1st. All of this seemed to coincide with Midnight and CG's connection to Greece's Black Lotus Records. But the hype was short lived, when Black Lotus abruptly announced they were bankrupt and dropped all existing contracts with bands. Although this must have taken quite a bit of wind out of their sales, CG seemed initially committed to tour Europe despite the setback.
[Apparent mugshot photo, taken of Midnight in 2007 after having been arrested for a driving under the influence]
"On January 22, 2007, Midnight was arrested and charged with driving under the influence with a blood-alcohol level of .20 or higher. Four days later, the band parted ways with Midnight, saying it would be difficult to work with him "as his current state of mind and his present physical condition would impede plans we have in place for future appearances, releases and recordings.""
John Patrick McDonald Jr.'s dark and obscure journey ended on July 8th, 2009, when he died at 3:30am "in hospital with family, friends and bandmates by his side...Although the press initially stated total kidney and liver failure, the real cause of death was a stomach aneurysm." Plans to record the "Divine Chaos" album seemed to have been abandoned at that point. A "tribute show" was announced on July 5th 2009, where the band would headline the ProgPower 10 festival in Atlanta, Georgia. The date? September 11, 2009.
["my dream was always to be a famous rock drummer" - Todd La Torre, who assumed vocal duties in Crimson Glory after the death of Midnight, and later joined Queensryche, replacing Geoff Tate.]
IT JUST HAPPENED
I'm not saying it isn't plausible, but it's pretty extraordinairy when some drummer playing full time in Florida's cover band circuit for 20 plus years suddenly finds himself on stage doing the lead vocal parts of a singer some think rivaled Geoff Tate in the 80s. It's even more extraordinary when that same drummer - er, I mean, SINGER, resigns from that band while en route to REPLACE Geoff Tate himself in Queensryche!
The short version of this extraordinary journey is summed up by Todd thusly: "It just happened." The long version starts with ProgPower 10 in 2009, where Crimson Glory was apparently asked to play. They ended up headlining, and promoting it as a Memorial Show to Midnight, with a series of guest vocalists. On 9/11/2009. Todd "was added a few weeks prior by Matt LaPorte [RIP]."
"It is both a privilege and an honor to perform at this well-established and highly respected American metal fest, and we see this as a beautifully serendipitous opportunity to pay a final and meaningful tribute to Midnight in a truly special manner by including the fans, as well as a stretching of our collective wings in anticipation of a new era of CRIMSON GLORY." - Statement by the band"
The list of guest vocalists who sang on this "serendipitous" occassion included Wade Black (Crimson Glory/Leatherwolf), Zak Stevens (Savatage/Circle II Circle), Lance King (Pyramaze/Balance of Power), Nils K. Rue (Pagan's Mind), Chris Salinas (Zero Hour/Power of Omens), Ronny Monroe (Metal Church), Andy B. Franck (Brainstorm/Symphorce/Ivanhoe), Sean Peck (Cage), Danilo Herbert (Mindflow), Joakim Brodén (Sabaton), Michael Eriksen (Circus Maximus), Urban Breed (Tad Morose), Rob Rock (Impellitteri), Mark Boals (Royal Hunt), Clay Barton (Suspyre), Kelly Sundown (Beyond Twilight/Darkology), David Van Landing (Crimson Glory/Michael Schenker Group), and of course, Todd La Torre.
On May of 2010, CG announced to the world that Todd was their new singer. His first show with them occurred on October 30th of that same year, and a tour, dubbed "Phoenix Rising," commenced on 4.28.2011.
RISING WEST
Red gates of iron cast their black shadows on this land, dividing souls far below. The gathering winds, the army's watch are RISING from the WEST, fortelling news of freedom's hand - Before the Storm, from Queensryche's "The Warning" album
Crimson Glory seemed fairly stable for the next couple of years after recruiting their new drum - I mean SINGER--- but a new album remained evasive [was kind of wondering if they'd revive the old "Metatron, Lucifer, and the Divine Chaos" idea]. Then something very interesting happened in May of 2012. The ubiquitous comparisons to Queensryche throughout the years seemed to manifest into a bridge, connecting the 2 bands via Todd La Torre, who was asked to join the side project of Michael Wilton, Eddie Jackson, and Scott Rockenfield. The latter 3 individuals had just fired Geoff Tate from Queensryche, and needed to do something while legal court proceedings were in process. Hense - Rising West was born.
With Todd La Torre as their vocalist, Crimson Glory was working on a demo entitled "Garden of Shadows." But I guess the SHADOWS grew too long on this GARDEN, and Todd announced he was leaving the group at some point in 2013, approximately 3 years into his tenure with them. On 4.28.2014 Todd's bandmates in Rising West won the legal rights to the Queensryche trademark and Rising West effectively BECAME the new Queensryche, with Todd La Torre formally taking Geoff Tate's vacant position.
PERSONAL DEMONS
This journey into the history of Crimson Glory and their time with Midnight has left me significantly unsettled and unresolved with regard to my attempts at an interpretation of what it all means. More than anything, there's a palpable feeling of sadness and wonder. Why couldn't someone or something extract Midnight from whatever dark abyss pulled inexorably at him? I suppose the most conclusive statement I've read on the topic is right at the top of this page, taken directly from the band:
"As is the case with all truly great artists, Midnight was hounded by his demons..."
Of course, there's always more to the story. And if you've read my blogs or watched my videos regarding Queensryche, then you are probably familiar with my loose theory that a "proper sacrifice" was never made for their fame and fortune, at least not in any form I can conclusively detect. This seems to me, a possible explanation for the band's painfully long decline over the years, followed by a decidely messy and well publicized implosion. Without a suitible sacrifice, the band abandoned any hopes at recapturing whatever mystical energy pushed them into mild mainstream success in the early 90s, and settled back, for a time, into whatever was left of their loyal "prog metal" fan base.
With all of the comparisons to Queensryche, Crimson Glory has perhaps been doomed [or blessed, depending on who you ask] to inhabit the sacred halls of true underground metal for eternity, never to see their own "Silent Lucidity" or "Jet City Woman" rise to the top of the charts.
Maybe the true purpose of Crimson Glory was to provide a sacrificial altar, upon which their enigmatic singer would be offered up, not necessarily for his own band, but for another. I don't know about you, but that would probably turn me into an emotional wreck and I'd need to do something about it. Midnight "did something about it," and it destroyed him.
SOURCES:
Wikipedia, Epigram for the last straw, Blabbermouth, Bravewords.com, heartofmetal.niceboards.com, www.allsoulsmidnight.com, alchetron.com, metal-temple.com, youtube, google, www.heraldtribune.com
RELATED:
This blog was researched, written, and continues to be maintained by 1 person. If you enjoyed it and would like to encourage more of them, donations can be made by clicking the button below.


























